So far 2010 has been an exceptionally challenging year for most investors. In my experience, nothing drives investors more mad than headline-charged markets that make no progress. High volatility without a defined price trend has left both amateurs and professionals frustrated. The environment has been so challenging that even some of the world’s most successful hedge fund managers with stellar 20-year track records are throwing in the towel– many stating they just can’t generate a return in this environment.
It’s not much of a surprise. At the start of the year we postulated that the overall equities market was headed for a protracted environment of high volatility and little progress. We used the 2004-2005 time frame as an example of the type of environment we may be headed for. The reason is quite simple: After periods of high velocity (2000-2002 Dot Com Blow Up, followed by the 2003 Fed Liquidity Rally) the market regularly enters a period of congestion, digesting the recent highly emotional trading.
2010 Market Challenges
So far in 2010, the markets have lived up to the forecast, delivering a roller coaster ride of extremes with little return to show for it. We’ve endured new lows in housing prices, a “flash crash”, Greece debt defaults….and the ad nausea argument over the possibility of a “double dip” recession, and yet after a spectacular record breaking September, we find the S&P 500 back to almost even on the year. I have a long list of professional traders and hedge fund managers who all share the same feeling that 2010 has been one of the most difficult investment environments in decades.
It seems that not a day goes by that a headline about inflation, double dip recession or the incredible national debt doesn’t generate mass conversation and debate. Everyone has an opinion, and few are fearful about expressing it. The result has been a chaotic market environment of starts and stops.
The monthly chart below illustrates just how wild things have been this year. Take a look at the monthly volatility of even large cap, mostly blue chip stocks of the S&P 500 Index. Can you identify the trend?
Hedge Fund Managers Throwing in the Towel
Two weeks ago I was having a conversation with a well-regarded hedge fund administrator about the current environment. She made a comment that struck me as odd, stating that it looked to her like 2010 was even more challenging than 2008 for most long/short equity funds. That’s quite a statement considering 2008 saw the S&P decline by almost -40%. Long-Short Equity is by far the single largest category for hedge funds.
She’s not alone in her observation. Several well-regarded hedge fund managers with outstanding long term track records are shutting down their funds.
Forbes recently reported:
“Paolo Pellegrini, a protégé of housing market short-seller John Paulson, would return money to outside investors by the end of September, though he would continue to manage his own money after challenging markets put pressure on his big bearish bet on global economies. Just two days ago, Stanley Druckenmiller announced plans to shut down his $12 billion Duquesne Capital Management, citing burnout after a 30 year career. Duquesne, which has never had a losing year, is down 5% in 2010. At least 8 hedge funds run by billionaires are flat or down so far this year.
-Aug 20, 2010 Forbes Online.
As my Forbes colleague reported earlier this week, billionaire money managers are going through a rough patch. “While some of their hedge funds posted strong returns for 2009, after a disastrous 2008, others didn’t fare so well and 2010 has been tough. At least 8 hedge funds run by billionaires are flat or down so far this year.” -Aug 20, 2010 Forbes Online. Full Article
John Botti is shutting down his $402 million Emrose Capital, telling investors he’s no longer confident he can preserve their capital in such volatile markets. Full Article
Mr. Pellegrini, Mr. Drunkenmiller and Mr. Botti aren’t alone. Eight months into the year, a look at any of the various hedge fund indexes illustrates the flat performance this year for long-short equity strategies.
|Hedge Fund Market Indexes||YTD 8-31-2010|
|Barclays Equity Long/Short Index||-1.0%|
|Barclays Equity Long Bias Index||-1.8%|
|CSFB Tremont Long/Short Equity Index||-1.9%|
|Broad Market Indexes||YTD 8-31-2010|
|S$P 500 Index||-5.9%|
Where’s the Return?
During more normalized markets, there is a healthy buying and selling across market asset classes, sectors and industry groups. For example, while Healthcare and Biotech stocks may be declining -1% for the day, Retail and Financials may be +1% for the day as money flows from one group to another. Many times even during major market declines, certain market sectors will outperform others. This difference in sector or industry performance is referred to as the “spread”.
Not only have there been few consistent trends in 2010, but the correlation across asset classes such as Stocks, Bonds and Commodities has risen to historic levels. In simple terms, there has been little difference in the performance of one market sector versus another. On large rallies every sector is up, and on big declines every sector is down. The result is a market that is trading as one giant asset class, throwing the idea of asset class diversification out the window, and creating a real challenge for Global Macro hedge fund strategies.
The chart below illustrates how highly correlated all asset classes have become with stocks.
It hasn’t been much easier for Long/Short Equity. One of the most popular Absolute Return investment strategies in the Long/Short Equity space is buying quality, leadership stocks while simultaneously selling short low quality lagging stocks. Similar to the Global Macro example above, these strategies benefit from the spread between leaders and laggards.
Below is a chart that measures the spread in performance of those stocks in steady uptrends, and those in steady down trends. It is a visual picture of the differences between leaders and laggard market sectors.
Notice how even during the horrendous market decline of 2008 there was a spread between quality and low-quality stocks. That spread is near extinct for the past year, marking the clear challenge to long/short equity strategies. The stock market has entered a world where any given day is either BUY IT ALL or SELL IT ALL – and every sector of equity, commodity, rates and FX markets react in synchronized fashion
High Anxiety Markets.
After the last 9 months of market extremes investor anxiety is building. If this is you, let me put the proverbial experienced, reassuring physician’s hand on your shoulder. We’ve been here before, the current environment is no surprise to us, and flat returns this year are to be expected for Absolute Return managers. However as we enter the fourth quarter, there are several catalysts that may provide outstanding opportunity.
Our views at the beginning of the year for flat results were correct. When it’s raining, do you increase your driving speed? No, you reduce your speed until the windshield is clear. It’s no different when it comes to investing. There are times to increase exposure to the markets, and times to reduce it. We have been muddling through a congested market with few opportunities, managing downside volatility and patiently waiting for trends to emerge. The wait may be just about over.
The Stage is Set for the 4th Quarter
There are a few things brewing under the surface that may be catalyst for an explosive fourth quarter. First, flows out of equity mutual funds into more safe havens are nearing record highs. The general public remains extremely skeptical, which is often a contrary indicator to future price moves.
Second, the Federal Reserve has been injecting record amounts of liquidity into the markets through the purchase of various treasury based securities, through it’s POMO program. (More on this in a future commentary) History has shown that these injections of cash eventually find their way into liquid assets such as stocks and bonds, reflecting significantly higher prices three and six months out.
Third, as you can see from the tables above many of the best hedge fund managers in the world are flat to down on the year. As the market indexes creep back to break even, incredible pressure will be placed on those managers to once again become fully invested for fear of lagging their investment bogey. If the markets begin to rally into the fourth quarter, mutual fund and hedge fund managers will be forced to increase exposure to equities, creating further demand and higher prices. Of course this is not a projection, but merely an observation of a potential catalyst.
I believe we are more than half way through this consolidation of trends, and just a little more patience is required before Long/Short equity investors can reap substantial rewards. In the mean time we will continue to execute our investment strategies with disciplined risk management.